Why conservatism isn’t as funny
I don’t know if you remember the (thankfully) short-lived Fox version of “The Daily Show,” “The Half Hour News Hour.” You shouldn’t. It was awful. If you’d like a sample, try this on for size:
Yep. Nearly four minutes for one, prolonged sexual harassment gag. “Hey, look! That pretty lady is harassing that man. He clearly enjoys it. Isn’t it funny how politically correct crap like sexual harassment is funny when you use irony to skewer the situation?”
Whatever. The point being, it bombed. Partly it was, I think, because the anchors were actors, and the material didn’t actually use much real news as the fodder. Say what you want about “The Daily Show,” you may actually learn something.
Now we hear, in a study from the Inernational Journal of Press/Politics, that liberal and conservative students find “The Stephen Colbert Show” equally funny… though conservative students think he’s kidding. About his kidding. According to them, Colbert actually believes the outrageous things his character says, and is only pretending to be joking. The conservative students also believe that Colbert “dislikes liberalism.”
Yeah. Right [note to conservatives... that was sarcasm]. From the “Newsweek” article on “truthiness,”
He’s also got three kids he dotes on. He won’t let them watch his show. “I say things in a very flat manner that I don’t believe, and I don’t want them to perceive Daddy as insincere,” he says. “I basically tell them I’m professionally ridiculous.” At one point while he’s preparing for that evening’s interview, his assistant comes in and says that Conan O’Brien wants him on his show. OK, says Colbert, but only if it doesn’t conflict with taking his son to swim practice. “There couldn’t be a huger difference between the character Stephen and the real Stephen,” says Richard Dahm, one of the “Report” head writers. “The real Stephen is an amazing guy. The character Stephen–well, I wouldn’t want to be working for him.”
Emphases mine.
What is it about conservativism that, to be blunt, is less funny? And less likely to understand funny? I’m not being ironic here, or just peevish… I’m honestly interested.
My initial theory is that conservativism, being less flexible, leaves its adherents with less of an ability to see the absurd bends of reality necessary for much humor. In this case, I’m not digging on conservativism; it is, I think, a truism that a set of beliefs that wants to maintain something has fewer options than a belief set that embraces change. There are many ways to be liberal; many things to want to change. If you want things to stay the same, you focus on how they are (or were). Humor often requires the ability to see the object of the joke in at least two ways, or to see the irony in things… and irony requires two viewpoints (at least).
There may be other reasons. I’ll think about it some more.
April 26th, 2009 at 9:03 pm
That’s a good question that I never cared about until you asked. I’m not sure that conservatism is inherently less funny - I think the type of conservatism you’re referring to relies on ignorance for its survival. It may be funny to watch (when it isn’t being scary) but it’s hard to be witty or clever when yer not, duh, witty - or clever.
Conservatism and ignorance don’t necessarily go hand in hand - conservative leaders just seem to be good at capitalizing on it.
April 27th, 2009 at 9:08 pm
You may be right, sir. Strident liberalism is just as un-funny as strident conservativism. Maybe. Then again, even the funny conservatives (Buckley) are more “witty” than “funny.”
April 7th, 2010 at 10:18 am
Our major issue in this country is our two political parties. Our forefathers knew that a two party system would be our downfall and took steps to try to stop this type of politics, and thus anyone who seriously thinks that politics isn’t corrupt or slaves to Corporate America hasn’t not been paying attention. George Jr. will go down in History as one of the worst administrations in history and I could go on for hours showing why, but my point is that the Obama administration has offered nothing different (besides health reform, granted) and has in fact continued nearly every single Bush program. Obama has almost the same political donors and thus has the same pressures as Bush did. Health reform will turn out to be the most expensive and destructive waste of tax payer money ever. I just wish I could offer a better alternative for other frustrated people, but I can’t and those that think that the tea partiers are the future, remember that Sarah Palin is an important figure to them.
May 2nd, 2010 at 11:29 am
The Kreg Jig takes advantage of a technique called Kreg Joinery. Unlike other techniques, Kreg Jig requires no glue, no complicated math, and no small army of clamps to make wood joints that will last.
May 2nd, 2010 at 12:05 pm
The Kreg Jig Pocket Hole System (K4) is the perfect choice for do-it-yourselfers and anyone new to Kreg Joinery. Whether you’re building your first set of garage storage shelves or making simple repairs around the house, the Kreg Jig Pocket Hole System can help you finish the job in less time, and with far less effort than you ever thought possible.
May 3rd, 2010 at 2:54 pm
I saw Conan on tour the other night and it was awesome. I can’t wait for his new show to come on TBS. It will be the start of a new chapter in late night TV.